Decades of Insurance Leadership

Since James T. Domino established Domino Insurance Agency in 1979, our independent insurance agency has grown to provide insurance coverage to large and small businesses, and we hold multiple licenses around the country. Over the years, we have become recognized for the leadership and service of our experienced, professional team. We are proud to play an integral role in the businesses and lives of our clients, and we welcome the opportunity to serve you.

Independent to Better Serve You

In addition to establishing trusted relationships with our clients, we also develop strong relationships with insurance companies we trust. What that means for you is that we can offer you a wide variety of coverage options so you can have the power of choice in protecting what’s important to you.

domino insurance building

Advantages of Working with an Independent Agency

We Represent Multiple Insurance Companies

We represent different insurance companies so we can offer you a variety of policies unique to you. We do the shopping and the hard work when it comes to helping you find insurance.

We Are Insurance Advisors

We want you to make an informed decision on your insurance coverage. Through education, we work to simplify the process so you can make an informed decision based on your needs.

We Are By Your Side Every Step of the Way

You’re never on your own when it comes to your insurance. We’re here for you and work with the insurance company on your behalf.

We Offer a Wide Variety of Insurance Solutions

Your insurance needs are unique, your insurance coverage should be too. We find insurance solutions for you by offering a wide variety of coverage options.

We Are There for You in Your Time of Need

Signing the dotted line is not the last step, it’s the first step of our relationship to you as our client. We’re there for you when you need us most to guide you along the way.

We're Dedicated to Our Clients. See What They Have to Say About Us

I purchased commercial insurance for my property. Alex took time to explain and is always willing to answer any questions.
Mohammad Riaz
via Google
Everyone has been very helpful in getting the best coverage for our insurance needs
Cary Hewitt
via Google
I've been a customer of Domino Insurance for several years now, and I couldn't be happier with the service I've received.
Eric Nelson
via Google
Great service and very knowledgeable.
Dr. Roseanne Palermo
Roseanne M. Palermo, DMD
Alex has been incredible for us! A miracle worker. We recommend Domino insurance to everyone.
Rick E
via Google
Amazing service! Great rates, very professional!
joni townsend
via Google
Great staff here! Easy to work with when dealing with all of our insurance needs.
Summit Auto Inc
via Google
Great company, great service! You are listening me and all my needs are met. Thank you!
Aleksandr Cheremnykh
via Google

 Why should an Erie business choose an independent agent like Domino Insurance instead of a direct carrier? 

Choosing Domino Insurance Agency gives your business access to multiple top-tier insurance carriers rather than just one. This independent advantage allows our team at 3209 Greengarden Blvd to shop the market on your behalf, compare commercial rates, and customize a policy that offers the strongest protection at the most competitive price point.